Good Coffee Map

Decaffeination: every method with pros and cons

Swiss Water, CO₂, sugarcane or solvents: how caffeine gets out of the bean, what it means for flavour and how to spot a good decaf.

Published November 22, 2026

Swiss Water

solvent-free, mild

only water and activated carbon filters

CO₂

gentle, good for large volumes

carbon dioxide under high pressure

Sugarcane (ethyl acetate)

fruity-sweet, popular in specialty

solvent made from fermented sugarcane

Methylene chloride

cheap and effective, controversial

classic solvent

Every method works on green coffee, before roasting.

The basic idea

  • Decaffeination always happens to green coffee, before roasting.
  • The beans are swollen with water or steam so the caffeine dissolves.
  • Then something pulls the caffeine out: water, CO₂ or a solvent. The beans are dried and roasted as usual.
  • It was invented by Bremen merchant Ludwig Roselius, founder of Kaffee HAG. The process was patented in 1906, back then using benzene.

The methods compared

MethodHow it worksProsCons
Swiss Waterbeans soak in water, caffeine is filtered out with activated carbon, the flavour-rich water is reusedno chemicals, suitable for organicpricier, flavour can be flatter
CO₂ (supercritical)carbon dioxide under high pressure dissolves the caffeine selectivelyvery selective, flavour stays intactexpensive plants, mostly for large volumes
Ethyl acetate (sugarcane)a naturally occurring compound, often made from sugarcaneoften fruity-sweet, common in Colombiastill a solvent, can taste slightly fruity
Methylene chloridesolvent applied to the beans or to the soaking watercheap, fast, little flavour losschemical solvent, residues strictly limited

How much caffeine is left?

  • In the EU, decaffeinated roasted coffee may contain no more than 0.1 % caffeine.
  • So decaf is never completely caffeine-free; a cup holds only a fraction of the usual amount.
  • Depending on the method, about 94 to 98 % of the caffeine is removed.

How to spot a good decaf

  • The method is on the bag, often as Swiss Water, CO₂ or sugarcane.
  • Origin and variety are listed just like for regular specialty coffee.
  • Freshly roasted: decaf loses its aroma a little faster.
  • Many specialty cafés now offer a good decaf for espresso and filter.

More from the journal

Spotted a La Marzocco? Add