Light or dark roast, and what “specialty” actually means
Specialty coffee is more than a marketing word: it has a clear definition. Plus: what roasting does to flavour and why specialty roasters often roast lighter.
Published November 22, 2026
What specialty coffee means
Specialty coffee is a defined quality term. Trained tasters score green coffee in a standardised tasting, called cupping, on a scale of up to 100 points. Under the Specialty Coffee Association's definition, coffee scoring 80 points or more counts as specialty. On top of that come strict limits on defects in the green coffee, such as damaged or unripe beans.
Within specialty there are tiers: 80 to just under 85 points is very good, 85 to just under 90 is excellent, and 90 and above is outstanding. Only a small share of the world's coffee reaches this class at all.
Transparency usually comes with it: origin down to the region or farm, variety, processing, and often fairer, more direct buying.
What happens during roasting
Green coffee smells grassy and barely tastes like coffee. Roasting creates hundreds of aroma compounds through heat, sugars caramelise, and the bean turns brown and brittle. The longer and hotter the roast, the darker the bean, and the more the flavour shifts.
Light, medium, dark
- Light roast: lively acidity, fruity or floral notes, lots of origin character. Typical for filter coffee and modern specialty espresso.
- Medium roast: balanced, more sweetness and body, notes of chocolate, nuts and caramel. The most common compromise for espresso with milk.
- Dark roast: little acidity, strong, bitter-chocolatey to smoky. Roast flavours increasingly cover up the origin.
Why specialty roasters often roast lighter
Specialty coffee costs more because it takes more work on the farm and in processing. That work shows in the cup: an Ethiopian coffee can taste of berries or jasmine, a Colombian of red fruit and caramel. The darker the roast, the more these differences disappear behind roast notes. Lighter roasts let them stand.
Lighter is not automatically better, though. For espresso with lots of milk, many specialty roasters deliberately go a little darker so the coffee holds its own against the milk. What matters is that the roast suits the bean and the brew method.
How to spot specialty in a café
- The roaster is named, often a local one
- Origin, variety or process are listed on the menu or bag
- A roast date on the packaging, not just a best-before date
- More than one coffee to choose from, often including filter
More from the journal
- Espresso basics: ristretto, lungo, doppio, extraction and grind size
- Latte art: heart, tulip, rosetta and what is behind them
- Dairy, oat, soy: what milk does to your coffee
- Flat white, cappuccino, latte macchiato, caffè latte: the difference
- Why coffee should not be too hot
- Bean, barista, machine: why a La Marzocco is a good sign
- Made by hand in Florence: the story of La Marzocco
- Linea, Strada, KB90: how to recognise La Marzocco models
- How to spot a La Marzocco and add it to the map